December 08, 2013
Sunday Afternoon Prayer: Elizabeth’s Prayer
O Lord Our God,
You have declared that "my thoughts are not your thoughts,
Neither are your ways my ways.
As the heavens are higher than the earth,
So are my ways higher than your ways
And my thoughts higher than your thoughts."1
I've always known those words were true. But I didn't like them.
Most of my life I have not understood your ways.
I am not sure I do, even now.
Actually, I am pretty sure I don't.
All those years of waiting and longing.
When I was a little girl I dreamed of a good husband and the children I would bear him. It didn't seem like much to ask.
And my husband is a good man.
He is upright and follows you.
But the children never came to us.
Month after month after month of disappointment.
My friends had their first child, and their second, and their third...
And my womb lay empty and my stomach flat.
At every gathering, they would start to tell their birth stories and discuss the challenges of nursing. I have never felt so out of place. Like I was an imposter, a fake woman.
And all of those months I cried out to you.
"Please Lord, may this be the month."
"How long, O Lord, how long?"2
"Do not hide your face from me, my God"3
And you remained silent.
You did not answer me.
For all those years.
I tried to be patient while I waited. I really did.
But the shame was unbearable.
I know others whispered behind my back:
Who sinned? This woman or her husband?
I wondered myself. What have we done wrong?
And still you remained silent. I was left waiting.
As the years passed, I gave up hope.
I was too old to have my first child now.
My friends had become grandmothers.
So I tried to be faithful with the little I had.
I worshipped you. I kept your commandments.
I kept the Sabbath.
I honored my husband and our marriage.
I tried so hard to not covet my friends' children.
But the questions still gnawed at my heart. Your silence didn't help.
And then. Then it all changed.
Zechariah came home from his work in the temple.
He had gotten his once in a lifetime opportunity to enter the holy of holies.
But things were strange.
He couldn't speak. He had to communicate in writing.
And he scrawled on the board that I would become pregnant.
I didn't believe it. Now? After all these years?
But he told me about your messenger.
And slowly, I felt a tiny ray of hope warm my being.
Maybe it would be so. Maybe you wouldn't be silent forever.
And it was so. You heard my cry and you answered me.I look at this tiny babe in my arms, and I don't know what the future holds for him.
I want to keep him safe in my arms forever, but I'm sure that isn't your plan.
I know this is a special baby. A miracle baby.
And you have plans for him. I don't know what they are yet.
But you have proved that your ways are higher than mine.
Even during all those torturous years, you were faithful to your promises.
You heard my cry and finally answered me.
1Isaiah 55:8-9
2 Psalm 13:1
3 Psalm 27:9
Photo by Cary and Kacey Jordan, The Jordan Collective. Used under a Creative Commons License.
December 05, 2013
Boxing Lament, Creating Playlists, and Backwards Parties: Spiritual Practices for a Busy Generation
In the years since, I have read a number of such books at different points in my life. Each has a slightly different tone and focus. Most recently I read Who’s Got Time: Spirituality for a Busy Generation by Teri Peterson and Amy Fetterman. It is one of the newest titles in the Young Clergy Woman Project imprint with Chalice Press. Peterson and Fetterman are both youngish pastors and they wrote this primarily for people in their generation. People who grew up with computers. People who grew up moving frequently and far from extended family. People who are marrying later and later or not marrying at all. People who struggle to find work and if they do expect to change jobs regularly for the rest of their life.
Peterson and Fetterman do a great job of suggesting ways to practice spiritual disciplines (both classic and new) in the busy, hyper-connected life most of us live. I really appreciated their practicality and creativity. As much as a I respect Foster’s work, Celebration of Discipline doesn’t include a chapter on social media.
Here’s a sampling of some of the ideas that I found interesting (they cover more traditional disciplines, like fasting, too). Chapter two is called “In the Body,” and it explores “ways we can exercise our spirits as we live in flesh and bone.” One of their suggestions is to incorporate a piece of scripture into a boxing (or kickboxing?) routine. They say “Amy’s personal favorite combo includes Psalm 61:1 and goes like this: Hear *jab* my *jab* cry *right hook* O *left hook* God *backfist*.” I may or may not actually try this one myself, but a physical lament sounds awesome!
Chapter four is all about using music in the life of faith. One of my favorite ideas from the chapter I already shared on the blog—making playlists. They suggest peace and righteous anger playlists. I made a wait. hope. expect. playlist that helps me to wait with hope during this period of my life.
They also have a chapter on rituals that I found inspiring. They wonder “How do we organize our hopes, dreams, fears, realities, loves, losses, and find a sense of the Holy in the midst of them? How do we mark these life events that don’t have rituals already attached to them the way marriage or kids do?…We believe there is a way to create ritual that makes meaning out of the lives we live now, as twenty-first–century young adults” (ch. 5). One of the examples they give is a “backwards party” when one of their friends was moving away. They started by saying goodbye, ate dessert, then dinner, and ended with saying hello. It was a ritual that helped this group of friends to transition to a new phase of their friendship. I haven’t started any new rituals yet, but I’m thinking of opportunities.
There are lots more ideas in the book, and I would encourage you to check it out for yourself if you are looking to grow in your spiritual walk. I would add a note that I am a bit more conservative in theology than the authors, and a few ideas I’m not sure I’d be comfortable trying. But that doesn’t mean they don’t have lots of good ideas and true thoughts.
December 03, 2013
Loose Ends (Advent Psalms #1)
This reflection focuses on Psalm 27.
be strong and take heart
and wait for the Lord.Psalm 27:14
December 01, 2013
Sunday Afternoon Prayer: When The Timing Seems Wrong
God of time,
You are outside of time. Yet you created time.
That time plays a big part of lives. And sometimes, the timing just seems wrong.
The Israelite people wanted their Messiah to come sooner to rescue them.
Zechariah and Elizabeth longed for a child to be born for years.
Mary faced a too-soon-pregnancy.
Christians have been waiting for Jesus to return. For 2,000 years.
Some wait for a positive pregnancy test while others are overwhelmed with an unexpected pregnancy.
We wait to hear back about job interviews and scholarships, home sales and medical tests.
So often, the timing just seems wrong and our lives feel like they are crumbling.
How long, O Lord?
How long until you make “beautiful things out of dust”?
Jesus, you know time. You too had to wait until your hour came.
Help us as we wait! Give us strength and patience.
Help us to trust in your timing, that you are caring for us even when it seems like our lives are dust.
Help us to see glimpses of “hope…springing up from this old ground.”
In the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Amen.
With thanks to Psalm 13, Luke 1-2, John 2, and “Beautiful Things” by Gungor.
Photo by gilliu00_, used under a Creative Commons License.
November 28, 2013
Thanksgiving Standing Stones 2013
Travelling to the UK for three weeks in January. I got to experience the church and culture, which despite common stereotypes, caused me to say look what God is doing!
Performing my first baptisms of two young people that came to the United States as refugees. Their faith is rich, deep, and growing as they have faced many difficulties in their short lives. I am thankful that I got to be a small part of their stories.
I got to go on lots of short camping trips this Spring, Summer, and Fall. It was wonderful to spend lots of time outside hiking, eating, reading, watching birds, and enjoying the wonders of God’s creation. (If you’re curious, the photo is from May in Tahquamenon State Park Rivermouth Semi-Modern Campground.)
My pastoral residency at Church of the Servant, which ended at the end of July. This one is definitely bittersweet—I really miss being a pastor there, but I am so overwhelmingly grateful for the two years I got to spend there learning, loving, preaching, visiting, baptizing, welcoming, and being loved.
The two weeks I got to spend in Colorado and Wyoming during October. I spent time with Mary and Jared (my sister and brother-in-law), and my friend Allison and her family. I saw a whole new part of God’s creation—an exhilarating part. I even climbed mountains, sort of. At least I went on a short hike above the treeline.
Having a spiritual director who helps me each month to see what God is doing in my life. I am thankful for her support and encouragement that God is working in me, even when I can’t see exactly what God is doing yet.
I am so thankful for the gift of friends who have listened to me, waited with me, encouraged me, prayed for me, discerned with me, and loved me. I really would not have made it through these years without them.
“Save us, Lord our God, and gather us from the nations, that we may give thanks to your holy name and glory in your praise.”
Photo of spiritual direction feet by Michelle Kroll, used under a Creative Commons License. All other photos are my own.
November 26, 2013
Advent Calendar Printable
A few weeks ago, my sister wrote to me and asked if I had any suggestions for Advent calendars. She wanted to make one, but wasn’t sure of what activities to put on it that a) weren’t geared for kids and b) had some spiritual significance. I did a tiny bit of internet browsing and couldn’t come up with anything that was workable, either. So I decided to create my own. I assigned one scripture for each day and then an activity. The activities vary and are at least loosely connected to the scripture. Some samples: listening to “Zechariah and the Least Expected Places,” using Psalm 51 as a prayer of confession, choosing something joyful to do, and reading a passage with lectio divina (instructions included). Although this isn’t written specifically with children in mind, I think you could easily use it with older children and teenagers.
I enjoyed putting this together, and I’m looking forward to using it myself. If you are looking for something to guide your reflection during Advent and help you engage the themes of Advent—and the God who came in the flesh and will come again—please feel free to use it, too. It is available as a free printable. You are free to print and distribute this, but I do ask that you don’t sell it—I’m making it available for free and would like to keep it that way. Have a blessed Advent!
November 24, 2013
Sunday Afternoon Prayer: Confession for Christ the King
"This is love: not that we loved God, but that he loved us
and sent his Son as an atoning sacrifice for our sins.
Dear friends, since God so loved us, we also ought to love one another.”
November 21, 2013
Imaginative Reading and Building A File
But once I was a pastor, I didn’t read as much as I thought I would. I was busy with meetings, answering e-mail, writing sermons, visiting people, and many more tasks. One of my regrets about my first years of ministry is that I didn’t better protect time to read widely. When I did read, I didn’t take the time to note those passages and themes I should save for later, so my file stayed about the same size. On my list of things-I-want-to-do-better the next time I’m a pastor is read widely and be disciplined enough to add to the file.
Perhaps you are wondering why it is important for me to read as a pastor. Neal Plantinga has taken his thinking about this topic and discussions from classes and seminars he has led and crafted them into a new book called Reading for Preaching: The Preacher in Conversation with Storytellers, Biographers, Poets, and Journalists. The premise of the book is that preachers should read widely because it helps us gain wisdom, improve our use of language, interact with new ideas and people, and find the best material for sermons.
I studied English for my undergraduate education, and once I was in seminary I realized that all that reading and discussing and writing I did had taught me to do most of those things. I had entered Tennyson’s grief at the death of a friend in his poem In Memoriam A.H.H. I had grappled with stereotypes in Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice. I experienced Hester Prynne’s guilt and shame in The Scarlet Letter. All of those experiences make me a better pastor, preacher, and person.
Reading brings me great joy—I love getting to know new people through a novel or seeing things in a new way from a poem. Thankfully, Plantinga says to enjoy it. “Good reading generates delight, and the preacher should enjoy it without guilt. Delight is a part of God’s shalom and the preacher who enters the world of delight goes with God” (pg. x). Plantinga’s blessing and exhortation in this book really encouraged me to be more intentional about reading and the less delightful (but important) process of recording some of my discoveries.
At the same time, I have figured out some practical tips of what works for me which makes me much more motivated to do it. First, the question of what to read. My problem is usually having too many books to read at any particular time, but I often try to rotate through novels, non-fiction, and poetry. Plantinga suggests “Just one novel a year? And one biography? And one-fifth of a book of poetry by one poet? And a weekly visit to the website of Arts & Letters Daily to find out what the best journalists have been saying? Not a bad plan, I think” (pg. 42). Sounds doable, doesn’t it! Plantinga offers a “Selected Reading List” at the back of his book to get started from. Another way I like to select great books is from the Recommended Reading List for the upcoming Festival of Faith and Writing.
When I am reading, if it is a paper book I have small sticky tabs that I place at the place on a page where I find something interesting. Then, when I finish the book I go back through and if it still seems like something I want to save, I put it into the file. (I picked up that tip from an interview Plantinga did for the release of his book. Don’t ask how I had forgotten to ask him what his method is when I had the class with him.) If I am reading on the Kindle app on my tablet, I highlight parts I want to save. Then, when I am finished I go to my online Kindle account where you can see all of what you have highlighted. Anything I want to save gets copied and pasted into my files. Both of these methods have been working really well for me!
I keep my file in Evernote, which is a free software. You can create multiple notebooks with various notes in each. The best part is that I can tag each note with topics (love, grief, forgiveness, etc.). Then when I am looking for something on a theme, I check out what I’ve tagged with it. There is also a really convenient web clipper, which makes it really easy to save blog posts and online news clippings very easily. Keeping my file in Evernote has been a key to actually using this system; I started out doing it differently and it was too much work. (For the record, Evernote has no idea who I am, I just really like their software.)
I’m really looking forward to the day when I’ll be preaching regularly again and be able to use my file my often. It is a great feeling to know that I am investing time now that should pay off in the future. And now I’m off to Burma in a young adult novel I just started called Bamboo People.
November 19, 2013
Wait. Hope. Expect. Playlist
A few weeks ago, I was reading Who's Got Time: Spirituality for a Busy Generation. I'll write more about it in the coming weeks, but it is chock full of interesting takes on spiritual disciplines--one of them is creating playlists. I was inspired to make a playlist of songs that capture these three verbs. I have been playing it ever since, giving words and feeling to the waiting, helping to have hope, and encouraging me to expect that God is working. It starts with "From deep distress / and troubled thoughts / to you, O God / we raise our cries." It journeys to "a mass grave / no one can raise. / But you said "live" / and the ground it gives" and to God "slipping out of underneath rocks / in alleys off the beaten path." It ends with a benediction: "Christ be with me / Christ before me/ Christ behind me." Wherever you are on your journey, may these songs bless you as they have blessed me. If you have Spotify (its a free download), you can listen to most of the songs below. The three that Spotify doesn't have I provided a link to in the list below.
1. "From Deep Distress," The Water and the Blood, Sojourn
2. "Wait," Meet Me At the Edge of the World, Over the Rhine
3. "Keep Breathing," Be Ok, Ingrid Michaelson
4. "I'll Wait," Invisible Empires, Sara Groves
5. "I Will Wait," Babel, Mumford and Sons
6. "The Wait," Desire Like Dynamite, Sandra McCracken
7. "A Far-Off Hope," Love & War & The Sea In Between, Josh Garrels
8. "All the Stars," The Blood and the Breath, Caroline Cobb
9. "Love's Redeeming Work is Done," Love Shall Be Our Token, High Street Hymns
10. "Dry Bones," The Blood and the Breath, Caroline Cobb
11. "I Hope You Dance," I Hope You Dance, LeeAnn Womack
12. "Holding On To Hope," Faint Not, Jenny & Tyler
13. "Zechariah and the Least Expected Places," The Bewildering Light, So Elated
14. "He's Always Been Faithful," The Collection, Sara Groves
15. "Refuge," Over the Grave, Sojourn
16. "Strangely Ready," The Collection, Sara Groves
17. "Abiding City," The Builder and the Architect, Sandra McCracken
18. "Christ Be With Me," The Brilliance, Brilliance
October 22, 2013
Autumn Adventures
I’ve been pretty silent on the blog, but I’ve been having plenty of adventures in these autumn months.
Canning my mom’s famous salsa with four generations of my family (Grandpa, Mom, Cousin, Cousin’s son)
I spent a few hours exploring ArtPrize in downtown Grand Rapids. This was one of my favorite pieces, called Cascade.
I headed west for a couple of weeks. First, I spent time with my sister and brother-in-law in their new home in Colorado.
Mary and I drove up to Independence Pass, about 40 miles of mountain driving from their house.
It was peak color season for the Aspens and their vivid gold against the deep evergreens was spectacular. For anyone wondering, late September or early October is an excellent time to visit—the weather and trees are beautiful and it is considered “shoulder season” so things aren’t so busy.
Mary is talented and made a video of our time together. It features lots of footage of mountains, aspens, their canine companion, a gondola ride, and me awkwardly crossing a footbridge. You can see it on her blog.
Next stop: Laramie, Wyoming. This was a new state for me, and it was like no other place I’ve been to.
My reason for going to Wyoming: visiting my friend Allison, her husband, and infant son! It was so good to see them!
Back to Michigan: an impromptu lunch at Crane’s Pie Pantry with my mom—apple dumpling and apple cider…yum!
An afternoon hike to Hoffmaster State Park
Lake Michigan from Hoffmaster’s Dune Overlook
September 11, 2013
What I’m Listening To: Dry Bones
Dry bones
Hearts of stone
Slain and left
In the valley of death
Been dead so long
All the flesh is gone
A mass grave
No one can raise
But you said “live”
And the ground it gives
The bones start to rattle
And the darkness lifts
You give them blood and bone and
Hearts of stone to flesh
You give them muscle, skin
And life within the breath
Open graves
Bodies raised
The living breath
Reversing death
Written May 2011 for The Scripture to Music Project
Words and music by Caroline Cobb
From Ezekiel’s vision in Ezekiel 37:1-14; 36:26,27
Photo by _ChrisUK, used under a Creative Commons License.
September 02, 2013
Saugatuck Dunes Hike
To celebrate Labor Day, I took a hike I’ve been meaning to take all summer. I grew up going to the beach at Saugatuck Dunes State Park, but I had never really hiked there. My trusty Best Easy Day Hikes: Grand Rapids, MI told me that there is good hiking, too. So this morning I packed a lunch and set out. I took the South Trail, which the book says is 4.8 miles and the state park map lists as 5.5 miles.
The trail on the way to Lake Michigan was mostly through deciduous forests on a sandy, but firm, trail.
Shortly before Lake Michigan, the trail passed through the foredunes.
Almost to the beach!
On the beach, looking north. You can’t make it out in the picture, but I could see Big Red (the Holland lighthouse) in the distance. After snacking on the beach, I started out on the return trail, which travels through the foredunes and then zig zags up through blown out dunes. This part of the trail was harder than the first part! But looking back at the lake, the views were beautiful.
This is now one of my favorite dune hikes in Michigan! It has a more natural and remote feel than a lot of the parks (no stairs, for instance) and the dunes are extensive. I’d highly recommend it to anyone who wants to explore the dunes and is ready to climb through a lot of sand.
August 30, 2013
Goodbye, Grand Rapids
Tonight is the last night I will sleep in my apartment in Grand Rapids. For the foreseeable future, it is the last night I will stay in GR as a resident, and not someone’s guest. This is a sad night for me. This is the place I became an adult. I have lived here for 3/4 of my adult life. I went to Calvin College here. I went to Calvin Theological Seminary here. I had my first call at Church of the Servant here. Living in Grand Rapids has shaped me in so many ways.
People love to hate Grand Rapids; some call it “bland rapids.” It is not as big or as cosmopolitan as New York or Chicago. But Grand Rapids has its own charm. There are lots of wonderful places and things to do in Grand Rapids. Let me share a few of my favorites with you:
- Calvin College—where I learned how to be a thinking Christian mindful of the broader world
- Oakdale Park CRC—the church I attended while I was at Calvin
- Ice skating at Rosa Park circle
- Little Africa Ethiopian restaurant—a favorite place my friends would go when we were at Calvin
- $5 student tickets to the Grand Rapids Symphony
- Calvin Theological Seminary—where I did the formal education part of becoming a pastor
- Monroe Community Church—the church that loved me through seminary
- Kava House
- Art Prize—most interesting and fun thing that has started in GR recently
- The Green Well—a favorite with some of my seminary-era friends
- Peking Wok (which has very sadly closed)
- Eerdman’s Bookstore—they have a great selection of discount Eerdman's books
- Concerts at Calvin College—why didn’t I go to more when I was a student? They have really interesting artists
- The Festival of Faith and Writing—so many wonderful readers and writers gathered together
- Church of the Servant—where I became a pastor
- Summer concerts at the Fredrik Meijer Gardens Amphitheater
- Bethany Refugee Services and the hundreds of refugees that are resettled here every year
- Baker Books and Icons Coffee—wonderful bookstore and coffee shop really close to my house
- Kentwood Public Library
I don’t know where I am going to land in the future, but I am thankful for the ways Grand Rapids has shaped me, and I am excited to take that with me to my unknown destination. Thanks, Grand Rapids. Its been great!
August 18, 2013
Sunday Afternoon Prayer: Great is Thy Faithfulness
Loving and Faithful God,
For keeping a child of your covenant, baptized when he was an infant, safe in your hands,
Great is thy faithfulness.
For his parents who loved him and taught him about you,
Great is thy faithfulness.
For keeping Grandpa safe while he was deployed in the Navy,
Great is thy faithfulness.
For giving him a beautiful wife who loved him until her dying day,
Great is thy faithfulness.
For three children that he loved and supported (and is still very willing to help weed gardens or repair their homes),
Great is thy faithfulness.
For helping him to become a great teacher and principal,
Great is thy faithfulness.
For blessing him with grandchildren—both adopted and biological—that he loves deeply,
Great is thy faithfulness.
For saving his life from cancer,
Great is thy faithfulness.
For Grandpa and Grandma’s consistency at showing up at their grandkids events—church programs, piano recitals, sports games, etc.,
Great is thy faithfulness.
For the hours of volunteer service at Desert Christian High School, World Renew (formerly CRWRC) Disaster Response Services, Bibles for Mexico Thrift Stores, and other places,
Great is thy faithfulness.
For the love he shows his great-grandchildren through creating toys and babysitting,
Great is thy faithfulness.
For the love of and commitment to the church (there are few times I’ve heard him complain about it!) that he demonstrates to all of us,
Great is thy faithfulness.
For 90 years of following you,
Great is thy faithfulness.
Great is thy faithfulness! Great is thy faithfulness!
Morning by morning new mercies I see;
all I have needed thy hand hath provided.
Great is thy faithfulness, Lord, unto me!
Personal photo of my grandpa and me at my ordination, January 2012.
August 15, 2013
On My New Found Love of Poetry
Before this point in my life I have not been a huge poetry fan. I didn’t actively dislike it, but with few exceptions I didn’t love it, either. I am not the best poetry reader and I’m a worse poetry writer. I did read enough poetry when I was an English major to get a sense of styles I am drawn to and those I’m not (lets just say that T.S. Eliot will never be one of the 3-4 poets I dwell one).
So why did I start reading more poetry once I became a pastor? I don’t think it was just because Eugene Peterson said I should or the inner English major who always wished I was better with poetry. In the “Author Q & A” of Lauren Winner’s Still: Notes on a Mid-life Faith Crisis she talks about why she reads and writes about poetry. Winner bases her answer on an observation by Richard Rohr that our spiritual lives have two halves—the season where you build a spiritual identity and the season where you face crisis and come to know God in a deeper way. “Rohr says that in the second half of your spiritual life you may find yourself reading a lot of poetry. Maybe, before, you read dogmatics or self-help how-tos or narrative history. Before, poetry may have seemed elusive and loopy. In the second of Rohr’s two halves, you like the space that poetry offers” (pg. 205-206).
In the messiness of being a pastor, I like that space poetry offers. Every day I face questions and ambiguities about faith and life. There are the questions that inevitably come with reading scripture. There are difficult situations in people’s lives that pastors are called to walk through with them. There are specific applications of how we love our neighborhood, like do we help this person with their rent? And who am I in all of this; what does it mean to be a pastor?
In the messiness, poetry gives space. Space to be. Space to live with the ambiguity. Space to question and wonder and enjoy something beautiful. In her book about being good stewards of language, Caring for Words in a Culture of Lies, Marilyn Chandler McEntyre says, “poetry can teach us specific skills that we need now more than ever to cultivate if we are to retain a capacity for subtlety” (pg. 159).
Good poetry doesn’t try to give all the answers and tie everything up into neat bows. It isn’t full of platitudes. I appreciate that because it is honest and authentic. That's the kind of person I want to be, too—someone who can hold up to the pressure of the ambiguities in my own life and others lives. I don’t think that it is a coincidence that one of my favorite books of the Bible is Psalms, a book full of poems. In the psalms I find that same sort of honesty and authenticity as in other poetry. The psalmist doesn’t usually sugarcoat things. If he (or possibly she) is angry at God or feels wronged by God, he says so directly. The psalms don’t always wrap everything up neatly, although they almost always end with a statement of trust in God. The psalms, and other poems, give space to live with the ambiguity that comes from living in a broken world. Poems can also point us towards the hope that we have in Christ, that things are ultimately secure, even if they appear to be falling apart.
I’m going to keep reading poetry, to keep finding that space and keep honing my skill with language. I’ll keep sharing some of my favorite poems here, as I’ve done in the past. The poets I have read the most in the past couple of years (in addition to the Psalms) are Scott Cairns, Mary Oliver, Robert Frost, and Luci Shaw. The Poetry of Robert Frost is on my bed stand right now, so perhaps he’ll show up here next.
Photo by Liesbeth den Toom, used under a Creative Commons License.